Hello…this is my very first review for The Otaku Fridge.
When I first stumbled on Magic Knight Rayearth here in the Philippines, I was instantly taken by the lush visuals and great character designs to be expected from the talented all-female team at CLAMP. I thought it would be a lot different from typical shoujo like Sailor Moon. Little did I know that once I followed it, I would be sorely disappointed by the entire series as a whole.
I really wanted to like MKR but so many things just keep it from endearing itself to me. The art is extraordinarily beautiful, with great mecha design, wicked characters and sublime-if-not-ridiculously-absurd detailing (look at Hikaru’s second sword). I also loved the fully orchestral music, which may get a little monotonous at times but is very grandiose nonetheless—it adds a lot to MKR’s classy appeal.
MKR is personally hard to like because of the story and its lack of originality. It’s probably the fault of the translation crew here in the Philippines, but the whole series is patterned after your usual Mexican telenovela. I appreciate the RPG-style episodes and very good main plot, but an abundance of dragging parts sorely tested my patience. There’s a feeling of so much fuss being generated about the most mundane things…it leaves me thinking, “Why don’t the three girls just do something?!”
I mentioned the lack of originality…it’s most manifested in the names (which I found quite hilarious). Many characters, mecha and even planets are actually named after Japanese cars. I thought it was simply a fault in the local translation at first, but these names are true . Eagle’s “FTO” mech is a Mitsubishi coupe. Zagato’s brother “Lantis” and the planet “Autozam” are Mazda cars. The battleship “NSX” is a pricey Honda/Acura exotic. Worse, the home planet “Cephiro” is a Nissan luxury sedan! Good grief. It seems the character designers were left desperately wanting for “good” names…oh well…
The characters are fleshed out well enough, although I share another reviewer’s sentiments of Hikaru being the sole focus of MKR. When you want to highlight the friendship angle of any piece of literature, you don’t give the limelight to one person alone and leave the other “friends” high and dry. I personally wanted to see more of Umi’s and Presea’s characters because they possess the most enigmatic appeal (and because I got so damned sick of Hikaru).
I got to watch the MKR OAV later on. If you want your anime florid and languishing in its own welcome, the MKR series is for you. Ordinary otaku like me prefer the OAV even with its relatively weaker story—it cuts to the chase.
Too bad, CLAMP. The MKR series could’ve been a lot better.
Individual Rating: Art: 10; Story & Plot: 6; Characters: 7; Sounds: 9